| 1 year ago :: Jan 17, 2009 - 4:38PM #1 | |
|
I recently stumbled across the website for PublishAmerica, which supposedly publishes dozens upon dozens of novels from new authors, lets them have creative freedom, etc. I was curious to know if anyone had any experience with this company. |
|
| 1 year ago :: Jan 17, 2009 - 7:08PM #2 | |
|
I know of a couple of writers who felt good about their experience with PublishAmerica; although, one of them is doing 100 percent of his own marketing, and had sent me an autographed copy (for which I will always be grateful since he's a friend), but I'll tell you, there are numerous typos in the book. Now, nothing is ever perfect, but I read a lot and I have never seen that many typos in a book before. There is also a statement at the beginning that it was published exactly as the author wrote it. That's okay to a point, but where's the editor? As a writer, I love to believe I am perfect all the time with my copy, but reality says 'oh, come on'. As well as something is written, there is always room for improvement, even if it is only spelling corrections. His book is listed on Amazon, but he can't figure out how to get it into book stores and so on. An agent probably would have been the way to go, but that's another discussion. I've also read other comments about PublishAmerica that state they will publish absolutely anything for anyone; your work doesn't have to be special. They won't market for you and they ask for names of friends and relatives and so on under some pretext and then end up bothering these people to buy your book. Tons of negative stuff there. I guess you'd have to read their contract and make up your own mind, but I would wait for more comments to see if others here have had experience with them. I thought initially they were a pretty good deal since I had received positive comments from two authors I know. Then, I believe it was off the NaNoWriMo.org site, where I found a link listing all different publishers and PublishAmerica was in there and like I said, very negative things were said about them. It wasn't as if they cheated you in some way. It was only that they didn't really do anything for you as an author. You had to do everything yourself, and how they bother your friends and family. If you can handle that kind of thing, then I guess that would be okay, but I would seriously check them out a lot more to make sure you are getting the kind of services you think you are. Hope this helps some. Joyce |
|
| 1 year ago :: Jan 18, 2009 - 2:44PM #3 | |
|
Thank you, that was extremely helpful. At the moment I'm favoring the agent route, but PublishAmerica seemed to spring up and surprise me. Your post, however, made me consider the fact that there is a difference between simple creative freedom and COMPLETE freedom. I believe I'll wait for a few more responses and generate a decision from there. |
|
| 1 year ago :: Jan 18, 2009 - 3:12PM #4 | |
|
I found the link where there was a lot more information. You don't need to sign in or anything, you can just access the following. Go to NaNoWriMo.org, then click on I Wrote a Novel, Now What?, then at the bottom click on the heading Some Thoughts on Publishing, within that paragraph click on Preditors and Editors List of Potential Scams, then click on Book Publishers, then click on the letter P, then click on PublishAmerica. I did NaNoWriMo last November and when it was over, I went through the site to follow up on all the additional information they provide, and that's where I found the stuff about PublishAmerica. Very interesting stuff. I strongly recommend you check all this out. And yes, do wait for a lot more responses from here. Before you send anything out you've created, check them out, check them out, and then check them out some more! One of the groups in here is nanowrimo writers. I would suggest perhaps checking with some of the group's members. Maybe they can help you too. Joyce Oh, one more BIG source of information. Go to bbb.org and check the national site and then in the consumers' part where you can check a business, put in PublishAmerica. The Better Business Bureau has a load of complaints on file about them. |
|
| 1 year ago :: Jan 23, 2009 - 8:21AM #5 | |
|
At one point I considered "vanity publishers" and chose not to do it because (1) I didn't have the money to do it; (2) I read plenty of negative stuff about them. And PublishAmerica was one of them. From what I can tell, those sorts of outlets can work well for certain projects -- and authors who have been published through typical channels will sometimes use them in certain situations -- but I think they tend to prey on aspiring writers who like the idea of being able to say "Here's my book!" ... it's tempting, but if you go that route, tread carefully. |
|
| 5 months ago :: Oct 12, 2009 - 8:10PM #6 | |
|
Hi! About four years ago, I ran across PA also. I submitted the prolouge and first 3 chapters of my book, and within a week I had a contract, a deadline of completion, and everything else that excites a would-be-arthur. But, before I signed, I researched the PA company. All I found was bad things. Bad editing, non-attempts to deal with arthur complaints, etc. In the end, I didn't sign, and I believe I am all the better for it. Always research a publisher thoroughly before becoming entwined with them. Best of luck! |
|
| 5 months ago :: Oct 16, 2009 - 11:31PM #7 | |
|
I know absolutely squat about PA, however I was once published through iUniverse. The experience itself was great (though I did wrastle with their art department a bit over my cover), however I found myself dissatisfied in the long rung. Oh, I had a booksigning at my local mall and sold roughly one-hundred copies in the first two months after being published. Still, I would not go through a vanity publisher again even if my life depended upon it. Let me explain, but preface with: I blame no one but myself for the end result of my book. When you are an aspiring author, your prose needs to be edited for everything from simple spelling and grammar to logical flow and ease of reading. Unless you pay big time, most vanity presses do not edit your book for you. And you know what? Having a book with glaring mistakes is worse than having an unprinted manuscript with the same mistakes. Your book should be near-perfect by the end product. Glaring mistakes make you seem even more amauturish than someone who is unpublished. It's downright embarassing. And, I know this may a little thing, but it is very hard to sell a book in trade paperback format. This format from a vanity publisher is nearly as expensive as a hardcover from a traditional publisher. Now, trade paperbacks are known in the industry as paperbacks of high-quality (better than your traditional hand-sized paperback). Still, most consumers will only see a "paperback" and are very leery of paying a harcover price for it. Now, I knew iUniverse would not edit my book and I knew they would print in trade paperback. Still, I was too eager to get my work in print to wait for a traditional agent or publisher to pick up my book. And now I regret it. The end product is of mediocre quality. Most agents/publishers will not want to represent a work that has been previously published, especially one by a vanity publisher. I still feel my story is very strong, but I know I will not be able to get it published any time soon in the traditional fashion. If I ever want to see my story published for mass consumption, I will have to prove myself with other stories first. In the long run, using a vanity press has actuallu caused me more work than if I'd just had patience. We all hear of those stories where a vanity-published unknown author suddenly makes it big (e.g. Eragon), but we have to remember those are the rarest of exceptions. In my opinion, we should wait and get our work professionally published and introduced to the publish in the traditional fashion. |
|